Unfolding this month at the Lowe Art Museum is a tale of two painters
enthralled by African art.
For one, Adolph Gottlieb, such a fascination impelled him to create
his own language of stripped-down forms. Then he boxed these sleek little
circles and spirals into that stylish grid beloved by Modernists everywhere,
as well as by graphic designers in thrall to Martha Stewart.
For the other, Edouard Duval-Carrie, the arts of Africa are part of
a messy Caribbean mélange that becomes ever more complicated
and dangerous. The Beginning of Seeing: Adolph Gottlieb and Tribal Art
at the Lowe, incorporates paintings from the '40s and early '50s and
catches the artist on his way up, before he has reached the signature
forms of his career.
Gottlieb (1903-1974) was a seminal American Abstract Expressionist
who began collecting tribal art objects in the '30s. The so-called "burst"
paintings of his final years, produced mainly in the '60s, condense
the disembodied eyes he appropriated from African masks and other non-Western
art into a single, fiery explosion of color with the apocalyptic overtones
of a nuclear holocaust.
Edouard Duval-Carrie: Endless Passage, also at the Lowe, is a midcareer
retrospective of sculpture and painting by Duval-Carrie, a Miami-based
artist born in Haiti. Deeply entwined throughout his art are the myths
and arresting Creole aesthetic of Haitian Vodou.
This New World religion has been stained by the bloodied history of
the Middle Passage slave trade, but it has also been fed by a stream
or astonishingly varied cultural icons, from the luridly lifelike painted
statues of saints at Roman Catholic altars to Masonic insignia to West
African temple paintings.
MIGRATION
Unlike Gottlieb, however, Duval-Carrie has a first-hand link to the
transformations African art has undergone in its passage to the New
World. He is especially taken with the ritual story-telling power these
objects possess.
For him, the most pressing master narrative is migration, an apparently
endless passing from one place to another, a journey that can chart
departure points and destinations in Africa, Haiti and the United States.
In his solo show at the Miami Art Museum three years ago, he presented
a tour- de-force installation, called Migrations, that was part Vodou
temple and part Catholic chapel.
Though it reveled in the gorgeous sparkling surfaces of sequined Haitian
Vodou Hags, this work — with its painting of one Vodou spirit
morphed into an exotic SoBe dancer — was also fraught with tragedy.
It showed that even spirits were leaving an island mired in fatal desperation,
fleeing the legacy of leaders he has described as running the gamut
from "operetta emperor to demented shaman."
Mardi Gras au Fort Dimanche is an especially caustic stab at the Duvalier
dictatorship. Duval-Carrie's gripping four-part series of paintings
now at the Lowe, and on loan from the Bass Museum of Art in Miami Beach,
also describes that passage of migration with an accuracy both fanciful
and frightening.
In the brilliant sun drenched colors and relatively flat perspective
of tourist-friendly Caribbean landscape paintings, this series, Miloucan
on La Migration des Esprits, is arranged to occupy one vast wall in
the museum. They aspire to the grandeur of Old Master paintings in a
cathedral, and their scenes of capture, escape and paradise despoiled
resonate with Biblical urgency.
During the '50s, Duval-Carrie grew up in an upper-class family typically
disdainful of Vodou, but one that also looked the other way when maids
appropriated leftover bottles of Anais Anais perfume for pink cake-and-candle
stocked altars to the Vodou deity Erzulie.
"Everybody's aware of it," says Duval-Carrie in an interview
in his Design District studio. "Even the priests that come from
Europe. That's the first thing they find out, that there's this whole
world of the spirits."
As the brutalities of the Duvalier regime increased, Duval-Carrie's
family fled to Puerto Rico, where he spent his teenage years, though
his father kept the family business going in Port-au-Prince, and as
an artist Duval-Carrie has returned to the island frequently.
His sumptuously layered and colored paintings are a grand mix of history,
religion and decorative arts. They offer a startling blend of transplanted
West African religious lore and 18th-century French rococo, all marbled
with tropical colors and grafted onto modern-day stories of corruption
and displacement among vistas shaded by the Haitian royal palm.
AFRICAN TIES
Erzulie, a coquettish figure the artist has painted and sculpted frequently,
may be a not-so-distant cousin to a Fon deity from modern-day Nigeria,
a figure that's a quixotic combination of motherhood and sorcery. Scholars
have looked at other threads connecting Haitian Vodou figures like Danbala
— a serpentine spirit lushly redolent of water, wisdom and rainbows
— with West African deities and they've discovered many family
ties.
It's also possible that lwa, the Creole word for Vodou spirits, carries
linguistic links to the Fon world of "lo" for "mystery,"
and to the West African Yoruba word "lawo,” meaning "secret."
Erzulie is "a totally Haitian spirit," says Duval-Came,
"but you can see how French she is. She's the goddess or love,
the mulatto woman born out of the illicit relationship between the master
and slave."
However you parse the West African bloodlines of Haitian Vodou and
their passage into Duval-Carrie's painting and sculpture, it's Vodou's
syncretic layering of colors and design and sacred and secular sources
that are making the most emphatic stamp on Duval-Carrie's art.
QUIET BEAUTY
The Beginning of Seeing:Tribal Art and the Pictographs of Adolph Gottlieb
is a smaller, quieter show, in which narrative is gently suppressed
in the favor of cool formal patterns, that the artist often likened
to inscriptions or missives that would speak to the spirit rather than
the mind.
Many of the streamlined shapes he adapts from tribal art are encased
in a slightly uneven grid, to create what he called "pictographs."
He found precedents for this grid from such divergent examples as paintings
by Piet Mondrian and the cellular-like ribbon of forms woven in blankets
by tribes of the Pacific Northwest Coast.
Giving this show its added eloquence are examples from the Lowe's
permanent collection, especially Gottlieb's New York Night Scene, a
wonderfully concise painting that splices pillars of skyscraper strips
of color with the earthy, slightly ragged geometries of tribal art.
Posted on Sun, Jul. 20, 2003
Elisa Turner is The Herald's art critic.
elisaturn@aol.com
...